Why does my team go quiet when I walk into the room?

Let's talk about executive coachingBook a no-obligation discovery call

Why does my team go quiet when I walk into the room? It’s one of those questions that rarely gets asked out loud, but it sits there quietly in the background for a lot of leaders. You might not phrase it exactly like that, of course. It often shows up as a feeling instead. A slight shift in the room that you can’t quite explain, or a sense that something isn’t landing in the way you expected.

You walk into a meeting and, just before you arrive, there’s a bit of chatter, a few laughs, people settling into their seats. Then you join, and the atmosphere changes. It’s subtle, but noticeable. People sit up straighter, the conversation tails off, and suddenly the room feels more serious than it did a moment ago.

Or perhaps you’ve just delivered your update in a town hall. You’ve been clear, concise, maybe even engaging. You finish, open it up, and… nothing. No questions, no comments, no challenge. People are listening, but they’re not interacting, and that lack of response can feel a bit baffling.

Why silence is rarely a good sign

It’s tempting to interpret that silence as agreement, or even as a sign that everything is running smoothly. But in reality, silence rarely means everything is fine. More often, it’s a response to you. Not just to what you’ve said, but to how you show up.

That’s the part that can feel uncomfortable, because most leaders don’t set out to create this kind of reaction. In fact, many are working hard to be authentic, consistent and “themselves” at work. The challenge is that your team doesn’t experience your intention, they experience your behaviour. And when that behaviour shifts, even slightly, depending on the situation, the pressure you’re under, or the people in front of you, others start trying to interpret what that means.

The impact you don’t always see

They begin to make small, often subconscious calculations. Is this a moment to speak up or stay quiet? Will that idea be welcomed, or will it be shut down? Are they open to challenge today, or is this one of those meetings where it’s better to keep your head down?

Over time, that constant reading of the room, and of you, changes how people behave. Instead of focusing fully on the work, they’re managing the interaction. They’re working out how to land things with you, rather than simply contributing what they think.

And that’s where the real impact sits. Because when people are second-guessing you, even in small ways, it starts to affect their confidence, their willingness to contribute and, ultimately, the level of trust in the room.

Why your team goes quiet when you walk into the room: what’s really happening?

This isn’t about the moment, it’s about the pattern

When a room shifts as you walk in, it’s tempting to pin it on something immediate. A tone, a look, a rushed entrance. But more often than not, that reaction has been building over time.

It’s shaped by how people have experienced you across different situations. In meetings, in one-to-ones, under pressure, on a good day, on a tougher one. All of it adds up. And that shift doesn’t always look the same.

In some cases, people go quiet. The chatter drops off, contributions slow down, and the room becomes more cautious. People are listening, but they’re holding back, waiting to see how things unfold before stepping in.

In other cases, you might notice the opposite. The energy lifts, the banter increases, people start performing a bit more, trying to land well with you or get your attention. It can look like engagement, but it’s often still a form of managing the interaction.

So when the dynamic changes, people aren’t just reacting to that moment. They’re responding to a pattern they’ve already noticed.

Continues:

Bit Famous works with businesses and organisations
to help them communicate with confidence.

By Penny Haslam

MD and Founder - Bit Famous

Workplace Confidence

FREE resources for leaders and people professionals from Penny Haslam and Bit Famous

Sign up for my awesome Workplace Confidence email

Share this page

Copy link

Gender pay gap action plans – what does meaningful action look like?

Gender pay gap action plans: why visibility and strategic confidence are key to success

Why does my team go quiet when I walk into the room?

How to host a meeting that will set you apart and progress your career

How low confidence shows up as underperformance at work

Communicating upwards: why won’t my message land?

Why doesn’t my team remember what I say?

Measuring Workplace Confidence – What happens when you teach self-belief?

The simple goal setting tool that sets your team up for success

Inside the study: what we’ve learned from mastermind groups in police leadership

The power of colleague-led learning

A beginner’s guide to difficult conversations at work

Workplace Confidence Podcast

Where people professionals share the great work they do!

10 reasonsTo work with Bit Famous

Let's talkBook a no-obligation discovery call

FREE ResourcesFor leaders and people professionals

People are responding to what they’ve learned about you

Over time, your team builds a picture of you.

They notice if you’re warm, engaged and easy to talk to in a one-to-one, but quicker, more direct or harder to read in a group setting. They notice if your tone shifts when you’re under pressure, or if certain people seem to get a different version of you than others.

They pick up on the moments where you’re open and encouraging, and the moments where you’re less so. None of this is unusual. It’s part of being human at work.

But when those differences start to feel unpredictable, people begin to adjust their behaviour.

Instead of simply contributing, they start second-guessing. They draw on previous interactions to decide how to handle this one.

‘Invisible leadership influences’: the behaviours your team is reacting to

I’ve seen all sorts of “invisible influences” that leaders have on others in this way. Nothing extreme on the surface, but enough to shape how people behave around them.

The midweek shift

One leader who’s great Monday to Wednesday, then sort of loses it by Thursday and Friday. They become more impatient, less focused, a bit sharper in tone. Same person, different experience depending on the day.

It doesn’t take long for a team to notice that pattern. By the end of the week, people start to tread more carefully.

The leader everyone agrees with

Another head of a large business where everyone says yes. Not because they agree, but because the leader has a reputation. If they don’t hear the “right” answer, they can become dominant or visibly frustrated.

So people adapt. They agree more. They challenge less. Meetings become smoother on the surface, but you’re not getting the real thinking in the room.

Different versions in different settings

Then there’s the leader who feels like a completely different person depending on the context.

Warm, engaged and easy to talk to in a one-to-one.
Brisk, direct or harder to read in a group setting.

Or even within the same meeting, different people get a different version of them. Some experience a positive, engaged interaction. Others get something more distant.

When it feels inconsistent

I’ll bet you’ve got your own example of someone who behaves one way in one moment, and then changes completely an hour later in a different setting. It can feel like they have very little self-awareness.

And it’s not just in meetings where this shows up. It’s across day-to-day interactions, conversations, and moments under pressure.

None of this is unusual, but it does have an impact.

Your team is scanning your behaviour

When your behaviour changes from moment to moment, your team has to interpret you in real time.

They’re scanning for signals. Is it safe to speak here? Will that idea be welcomed or shut down? Are they open to challenge today, or not?

And those small, ongoing judgements shape how they show up around you.

What you can do about it: practical ways to show up more consistently as a leader

If any of this feels familiar, even slightly, it’s worth taking a closer look. Not with a heavy sense of self-criticism, but with a bit of curiosity about how you’re coming across and what your team might be experiencing.

And equally, as you read this, there might be someone else coming to mind. A colleague, a senior leader, someone whose behaviour creates exactly this kind of reaction. If that’s the case, it might be worth sharing this with them, gently and with good intent. Sometimes a different perspective is all it takes to prompt a useful shift.

Notice how your behaviour changes across meetings, pressure and different people

A good place to start is simply by noticing what’s happening around you.

When you walk into a meeting, what changes? Do people lean in, or do they hold back? Do conversations open up, or become more controlled? Do you tend to get honest input, or polite agreement?

Then turn that same attention onto yourself.

How do you show up when you’re under pressure, short on time, or being challenged? Do you become more direct, less patient, quicker to respond? Do you listen fully, or move things along more briskly than you realise?

This isn’t about fixing anything straight away. It’s about spotting patterns. A simple habit of jotting down a few thoughts after meetings or key interactions can be enough to start building that picture over time.

Be clear on what consistent leadership looks like for you in practice

Once you’ve got a sense of those patterns, it helps to get clear on what you’re aiming for.

What does being a strong, professional leader look like in practice for you? Not in theory, but in how you behave day to day.

It might be a calm, steady tone, even when things are moving quickly. It might be taking the time to properly listen before responding. It might be staying open to challenge, even when it’s uncomfortable.

The point is to define something you can realistically maintain. A baseline that people can rely on, rather than a version of you that only shows up when conditions are right.

Reduce the guesswork for your team by showing up consistently every day

From there, the work is in the consistency.

Not perfection, but a steady effort to show up in line with that standard across different situations. In meetings, in one-to-ones, in informal conversations, and especially when the pressure is on.

Because it’s that consistency that removes the guesswork for your team. It allows them to relax into the interaction, rather than trying to work out which version of you they’re dealing with.

Use your personal values to stay grounded when your behaviour is under pressure

Your personal values can be a useful anchor here.

Not the ones written in a company document, but the ones that genuinely matter to you. Things like fairness, respect, clarity or honesty.

When you’re clear on those, they give you something to come back to in the moment. A quick check against how you want to behave, particularly when you’re stretched or under pressure.

They act as guardrails, helping you stay aligned with the kind of leader you want to be.

Read the blog: Why reflecting on personal values can boost your colleagues' confidence and sharpen decision making.

Ask for honest feedback so you can see the gap between your intention and your impact

And finally, it helps to have someone who can hold up a mirror.

Someone who will tell you what they actually see, not just what feels comfortable to say. Someone who can point out the gap between your intention and your impact, and help you make sense of it.

That might be a coach, a trusted peer, or someone whose judgement you value.

Because the truth is, most of this sits just out of view. And having that external perspective can make all the difference when you’re trying to build a more consistent, confident way of leading.

Why self-awareness is the real shift for leaders

When you look at what’s really driving all of this, it comes back to self-awareness.

Because many of the leaders who create this kind of reaction simply don’t see it. They’re not aware enough to recognise the impact they’re having, or how their behaviour is changing from moment to moment.

And that’s the issue.

When your behaviour isn’t consistent, people don’t know where they stand. That uncertainty starts to erode trust and psychological safety. People don’t feel able to relax, to open up, or to show up as their best selves. Instead, they become more cautious, more measured, more likely to hold back.

Over time, that affects confidence at work. It affects contribution. It affects the quality of thinking and challenge in the room.

Research into leadership and emotional intelligence backs this up (Coronado-Maldonado & Benítez-Márquez, 2023). Self-aware leaders are more effective, more empathetic, and better able to inspire and motivate their teams.

Not because they get everything right, but because they understand their impact.

And once you understand your impact, you can do something about it.

Let's talk about executive coachingBook a no-obligation discovery call